Spend the Rental Tax Refund or Pay Down the Mortgage: The Compounding Math
Cash damming is a strategy where rental income is redirected to pay down a mortgage while the rental expenses are borrowed back on a line of credit, creating tax-deductible interest that generates refunds. The key to maximizing this strategy's benefits is applying those annual tax refunds back to the mortgage principal, which creates additional compounding savings beyond the original deduction.
The shared inputs
Take a homeowner with a $500,000 mortgage at 4.5% and a basement suite renting for $1,800 a month, or $21,600 a year. These are illustrative only.
Under cash damming, the full $21,600 of gross rent goes to the home mortgage. Roughly $9,000 a year of rental costs (the suite's share of property tax, insurance, repairs, utilities) is borrowed back on a readvanceable line of credit at an assumed 6.0%. That interest is deductible, because the borrowed money is traceable to a rental expense (see CRA Income Tax Folio S3-F4-C1). Assume a 38% combined marginal rate.
The line balance grows by $9,000 a year, so interest and the refund grow too. Year 1 interest is about $540, producing a refund of about $205. By year 10 the balance is $90,000, interest is $5,400, and the refund is about $2,050. Ten years of refunds total roughly $11,300.
Both scenarios use identical inputs. Only what happens to the refund changes.
Scenario A: Refund spent
Mortgage: 4.5%, $500,000
Annual rent redirected to mortgage: $21,600
Annual borrowed-back expenses: $9,000 at 6.0%
Refunds received over 10 years: about $11,300
Refunds applied to mortgage: $0
The refunds are consumed. The mortgage still falls on the strength of the redirected rent, but the refund contributes nothing to it, and the $11,300 is gone after ten years.
Scenario B: Refund to mortgage
Mortgage: 4.5%, $500,000
Annual rent redirected to mortgage: $21,600
Annual borrowed-back expenses: $9,000 at 6.0%
Refunds received over 10 years: about $11,300
Refunds applied to mortgage: all, each in the spring it arrives
Each refund shrinks the balance that accrues 4.5% interest. Compounded at 4.5%, the ten annual payments grow to roughly $12,960 of mortgage reduction by year 10. That is about $1,660 more than the $11,300 contributed, and the extra is interest the mortgage never charged.
Where the difference comes from
Two mechanisms are at work, and only one of them is compounding.
The first is the deduction itself. It turns part of your household's
Cash damming is a strategy where rental income is redirected to pay down a mortgage while the rental expenses are borrowed back on a line of credit, creating tax-deductible interest that generates refunds. The key to maximizing this strategy's benefits is applying those annual tax refunds back to the mortgage principal, which creates additional compounding savings beyond the original deduction.
The shared inputs
Take a homeowner with a $500,000 mortgage at 4.5% and a basement suite renting for $1,800 a month, or $21,600 a year. These are illustrative only.
Under cash damming, the full $21,600 of gross rent goes to the home mortgage. Roughly $9,000 a year of rental costs (the suite's share of property tax, insurance, repairs, utilities) is borrowed back on a readvanceable line of credit at an assumed 6.0%. That interest is deductible, because the borrowed money is traceable to a rental expense (see CRA Income Tax Folio S3-F4-C1). Assume a 38% combined marginal rate.
The line balance grows by $9,000 a year, so interest and the refund grow too. Year 1 interest is about $540, producing a refund of about $205. By year 10 the balance is $90,000, interest is $5,400, and the refund is about $2,050. Ten years of refunds total roughly $11,300.
Both scenarios use identical inputs. Only what happens to the refund changes.
Scenario A: Refund spent
The refunds are consumed. The mortgage still falls on the strength of the redirected rent, but the refund contributes nothing to it, and the $11,300 is gone after ten years.
Scenario B: Refund to mortgage
Each refund shrinks the balance that accrues 4.5% interest. Compounded at 4.5%, the ten annual payments grow to roughly $12,960 of mortgage reduction by year 10. That is about $1,660 more than the $11,300 contributed, and the extra is interest the mortgage never charged.
Where the difference comes from
Two mechanisms are at work, and only one of them is compounding.
The first is the deduction itself. It turns part of your household's
Read Next
Restructuring Your Mortgage Is Not a Rescue Mission
What a Mortgage Rate Discount Is Designed to Keep You From Noticing
Bank of Canada Cuts Won't Save Your Fixed Rate From U.S. Inflation
7 Debt Ratio Checks That Set Your Mortgage Ceiling Before Your Credit Score Matters