• Home
  • Should a 45-Year-Old with Debt Borrow to Fill an RRSP?
Should a 45-Year-Old with Debt Borrow to Fill an RRSP?
By Julie Sheremeto profile image Julie Sheremeto
3 min read

Should a 45-Year-Old with Debt Borrow to Fill an RRSP?

Borrowing to Maximize RRSP Contributions: When the Math Works

Borrowing to maximize RRSP contributions can pay off only under specific conditions: the investment returns must exceed the loan interest rate, the tax refund must go directly toward the loan principal rather than other spending, and your current tax bracket must be lower than your expected future bracket. For most people earning under $100,000 with a mortgage, paying down the mortgage instead delivers a guaranteed return equal to the mortgage rate, making it the safer choice.

The Math on Paper

Assume an income of $95,000 in British Columbia. The combined federal and provincial marginal rate is approximately 31%. A $15,000 RRSP contribution generates a refund of roughly $4,650. If that refund goes directly to the loan principal, the net borrowed amount drops to $10,350. At a 7.5% loan rate (common for unsecured RRSP loans in 2026), the annual interest cost on the remaining balance is about $776 in year one.

The portfolio needs to clear that $776 plus inflation to break even. If the investments return 6% annually, the $15,000 grows to about $15,900 in year one. Subtract the $776 interest cost and you're up $124 nominal, or roughly break-even after inflation. The strategy works if the return holds and if the refund was actually applied to principal.

Now change one variable. If the refund is spent on a kitchen repair or a vacation, the full $15,000 remains outstanding. At 7.5%, the first-year interest jumps to $1,125. The portfolio still earned $900, but the net position is now negative. The investor is paying to own an RRSP.

The Guaranteed Alternative

Paying down the mortgage provides a return equal to the mortgage rate. If the $100,000 mortgage carries a 5.2% rate, every dollar applied to principal saves 5.2% guaranteed. No market risk, no timing risk, no behavioural risk.

For the same $15,000, applying it to the mortgage saves roughly $780 in interest in the first year. Less than the leveraged RRSP if the market cooperates, but certain. And the savings compound as the principal shrinks.

The RRSP loan wins only when the after-tax market return exceeds both the loan rate and the mortgage rate, and when the borrower has the discipline to redirect the refund immediately. Miss either condition and the mortgage paydown is the better move.

The Bracket Timing Problem

At 45, this borrower is likely not in their peak earning years. If income rises over the next decade, common in skilled trades, management, and technical roles in Kelowna and the Lower Mainland, the value of RRSP contribution room increases. Using that room now, at a 31% marginal rate, forfeits the option to use it at 43% or higher later.

The 2026 RRSP limit is $33,810. Unused room carries forward indefinitely until age 71, per CRA rules. Borrowing $15,000 to fill room today burns through space that might deliver a larger refund in five years when income has grown. The refund differential on the same contribution at 43% versus 31% is $1,800 per $15,000 contributed. That's the opportunity cost of contributing early at a lower bracket.

When It Flips

The loan strategy works cleanly in one scenario: high current income, stable employment, and a commitment to apply the refund to principal immediately. For a 45-year-old earning $120,000 in Ontario, where the marginal rate nears 43%, the refund is $6,450 on a $15,000 contribution. The net loan drops to $8,550, shrinking the interest drag and widening the margin for error.

For someone earning under $100,000 with a mortgage and little liquidity, the mortgage wins.


Sources

  1. Fidelity Canada - 2026 RRSP contribution limit: What you need to know - 2026-09-27. https://www.fidelity.ca/en/insights/articles/rrsp-contribution-limit/
  2. WealthNorth - BC Income Tax Calculator 2026 | Tax Brackets & Rates | WealthNorth - 2026-06-03. https://wealthnorth.ca/taxes/income-tax/british-columbia/
  3. LifeMoney - Marginal Tax Rate by Province 2026: Full Ranked Table - 2026-05-29. https://lifemoney.ca/blog/marginal-tax-rate-by-province-2026
  4. Justice Canada - Income Tax Act - Section 15.1 - 2026-01-01. https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-3.3/section-15.html