Fixed or Variable in 2026: How Much Room Is Left in the Variable Discount?
Five-year fixed mortgage pricing in Canada follows the Government of Canada 5-year bond yield, and that yield has been climbing into October 2026. Lenders have passed the increase through. The Big Six banks, for one, have all raised at least some fixed rates since early September. Variable rates follow a different input: prime, which moves with the Bank of Canada's overnight target. The central bank has described its next moves as data-dependent. So the gap between the two products is now set by two separate forces, and only one of them has moved recently.
That gap is the variable discount. A useful way to think about it: a fixed rate is a variable rate plus an insurance premium paid to the lender for cost certainty. The question is whether that premium is fairly priced for your situation.
Same mortgage, same five years
To compare the two fairly, give both the same job. The figures below are illustrative only. They are not current market rates.
Take a hypothetical $500,000 balance over a five-year term, with the variable rate 0.75 percentage points below the fixed rate at the start.
Year one saving: 0.75% of $500,000 is about $3,750 in interest. The real figure is slightly lower because the balance declines.
If the variable rate rises 0.75 points at month 12 and stays there: the two rates are equal for the remaining 48 months. Total saving stays near $3,750.
If it rises 1.5 points at month 12: the variable runs 0.75 points above fixed for four years. That costs roughly $15,000 against the $3,750 saved.
The rule underneath this: variable wins over the term only if its average rate across all 60 months stays below the fixed rate. A wide spread gives you more room for hikes before you lose. A narrow spread gives you very little. The timing of hikes matters as much as their size, because increases that arrive early weigh on more months. Keep in mind that, according to the Bank of Canada, policy changes usually take 18 to 24 months to show their full effects, so the hikes or cuts that matter to your term may not have been announced yet.
What the rate comparison leaves out
Qualification. OSFI's stress test applies to both products. Uninsured borrowers must qualify at their contract rate plus 200 basis points, or 5.25%, whichever is higher. At any contract rate above 3.25%, the qualifying rate is simply the contract rate plus two percentage points. A lower variable contract rate produces a lower qualifying rate. For investors adding a property in the Okanagan or the GTA, that difference can decide whether the deal is approved at all.
Exit cost. Breaking a variable mortgage typically costs three months' interest. Fixed penalties at many lenders are the greater of three months' interest or an interest rate differential (IRD), and the IRD can be large when rates have fallen since you signed. If you might sell, refinance or restructure within five years, this cost belongs in the comparison.
Payment structure. A variable rate mortgage with fluctuating payments passes every rate change straight through to your cash flow. An adjustable product with a fixed payment holds the payment steady but carries trigger-rate risk. If rates rise far enough, the payment stops covering the interest, and you face a lump sum or a higher payment.
Certainty. Fixed payments make budgeting simple. That value is real, but it cannot be priced reliably, and nothing here assigns it a dollar figure.
A middle path worth pricing
One option captures part of each: take the variable rate but make the payment the fixed rate would require. The extra amount goes to principal. That builds a buffer if rates rise, and you keep the lower penalty. It only works if the higher payment fits comfortably today.
Who each option suits
Variable fits borrowers with liquid reserves, steady or flexible income, and a real chance of moving or refinancing during the term. It also fits investors whose qualification depends on the lower stress-test rate. It works best when the spread is wide enough to absorb several hikes.
Fixed fits retirees and others on set incomes, rental properties in BC or Ontario where a payment increase would turn cash flow negative, and anyone whose reserves could not cover a trigger-rate call.
What would change the choice is the spread itself. If it narrows to the point where one or two increases would erase the saving, the premium for fixed becomes cheap protection. If bond yields keep pushing fixed rates up while prime holds, the variable discount widens. In that case it is worth running the five-year arithmetic again with your own balance and the rates offered to you.
Five-year fixed mortgage pricing in Canada follows the Government of Canada 5-year bond yield, and that yield has been climbing into October 2026. Lenders have passed the increase through. The Big Six banks, for one, have all raised at least some fixed rates since early September. Variable rates follow a different input: prime, which moves with the Bank of Canada's overnight target. The central bank has described its next moves as data-dependent. So the gap between the two products is now set by two separate forces, and only one of them has moved recently.
That gap is the variable discount. A useful way to think about it: a fixed rate is a variable rate plus an insurance premium paid to the lender for cost certainty. The question is whether that premium is fairly priced for your situation.
Same mortgage, same five years
To compare the two fairly, give both the same job. The figures below are illustrative only. They are not current market rates.
Take a hypothetical $500,000 balance over a five-year term, with the variable rate 0.75 percentage points below the fixed rate at the start.
The rule underneath this: variable wins over the term only if its average rate across all 60 months stays below the fixed rate. A wide spread gives you more room for hikes before you lose. A narrow spread gives you very little. The timing of hikes matters as much as their size, because increases that arrive early weigh on more months. Keep in mind that, according to the Bank of Canada, policy changes usually take 18 to 24 months to show their full effects, so the hikes or cuts that matter to your term may not have been announced yet.
What the rate comparison leaves out
Qualification. OSFI's stress test applies to both products. Uninsured borrowers must qualify at their contract rate plus 200 basis points, or 5.25%, whichever is higher. At any contract rate above 3.25%, the qualifying rate is simply the contract rate plus two percentage points. A lower variable contract rate produces a lower qualifying rate. For investors adding a property in the Okanagan or the GTA, that difference can decide whether the deal is approved at all.
Exit cost. Breaking a variable mortgage typically costs three months' interest. Fixed penalties at many lenders are the greater of three months' interest or an interest rate differential (IRD), and the IRD can be large when rates have fallen since you signed. If you might sell, refinance or restructure within five years, this cost belongs in the comparison.
Payment structure. A variable rate mortgage with fluctuating payments passes every rate change straight through to your cash flow. An adjustable product with a fixed payment holds the payment steady but carries trigger-rate risk. If rates rise far enough, the payment stops covering the interest, and you face a lump sum or a higher payment.
Certainty. Fixed payments make budgeting simple. That value is real, but it cannot be priced reliably, and nothing here assigns it a dollar figure.
A middle path worth pricing
One option captures part of each: take the variable rate but make the payment the fixed rate would require. The extra amount goes to principal. That builds a buffer if rates rise, and you keep the lower penalty. It only works if the higher payment fits comfortably today.
Who each option suits
Variable fits borrowers with liquid reserves, steady or flexible income, and a real chance of moving or refinancing during the term. It also fits investors whose qualification depends on the lower stress-test rate. It works best when the spread is wide enough to absorb several hikes.
Fixed fits retirees and others on set incomes, rental properties in BC or Ontario where a payment increase would turn cash flow negative, and anyone whose reserves could not cover a trigger-rate call.
What would change the choice is the spread itself. If it narrows to the point where one or two increases would erase the saving, the premium for fixed becomes cheap protection. If bond yields keep pushing fixed rates up while prime holds, the variable discount widens. In that case it is worth running the five-year arithmetic again with your own balance and the rates offered to you.
Sources
Read Next
Restructuring Your Mortgage Is Not a Rescue Mission
What a Mortgage Rate Discount Is Designed to Keep You From Noticing
Bank of Canada Cuts Won't Save Your Fixed Rate From U.S. Inflation
7 Debt Ratio Checks That Set Your Mortgage Ceiling Before Your Credit Score Matters