• Home
  • Canada's 60% Tax Bracket Belongs to Retirees, Not Bay Street Executives
Canada's 60% Tax Bracket Belongs to Retirees, Not Bay Street Executives
By Julie Sheremeto profile image Julie Sheremeto
3 min read

Canada's 60% Tax Bracket Belongs to Retirees, Not Bay Street Executives

A larger withdrawal from your RRIF should mean more money to spend. For some retirees it means a smaller share of each extra dollar arrives, because the same income that triggers tax can also start shrinking their Old Age Security. Two separate bills come from one withdrawal, and most people only plan for the first.

If you've ever looked at your RRIF balance while deciding whether you could afford a new roof, a renovation or help for a grown child, then wondered how much of that withdrawal would actually reach your bank account, you've already felt the problem. What matters in retirement is how much you keep after income tax and lost benefits together, and your tax bracket only tells you part of that.

Why your tax bracket understates what a withdrawal costs

OAS recovery, the clawback, works like this. Once your individual net income passed $93,454 in 2025, you repaid 15% of every dollar above that line, up to the full amount of OAS you received. Your official tax bracket doesn't show this. It's an extra cost layered on top of the bracket, which is why people call the combined figure an effective marginal rate.

You'll often hear that retirees in this range pay 60%. That number comes from adding 15 points to the top combined rates in BC and Ontario, which sit around 53.5%. But those top rates only apply to income well above $250,000, and by then OAS is already fully clawed back. The two never overlap. The 60% figure also ignores a detail that works in your favour: the OAS you repay is deductible against income tax.

Here's an illustration with a 40% marginal bracket. You take out an extra $1,000, and all of it falls within the recovery range. You repay $150 of OAS. Because that repayment is deductible, income tax applies to the remaining $850, which comes to $340. You keep $510 of the $1,000, an effective cost of 49%. That's painful, but it's well short of 60%. Your own figure depends on your province, your income and how much OAS you receive, so treat this example as a model of how the pieces combine and nothing more.

How the account you draw from changes what you keep

Go back to that roof. The cash you need is fixed. What changes is where it comes from, what else lands in the same year, and whose name it lands under. Before a large withdrawal, these four checks are usually worth more than worrying about which bracket you're in.

Estimate income for each spouse separately. OAS recovery is based on individual income, and household wealth doesn't enter into it. A couple with a combined $180,000 split evenly may never touch the threshold, while the same total weighted toward one person can cost that person part of their OAS.

Compare the RRIF with your TFSA. TFSA withdrawals don't count as income for OAS recovery. Funding a one-time expense from the TFSA can keep a year's RRIF income below the line. You can then rebuild the TFSA room later.

Model a rental sale before you list it. The sale price isn't your taxable income. What counts is the taxable portion of the capital gain. Add that to your pensions and RRIF payments for the year to see where you land. The timing of the sale can matter as much as the price.

Ask whether pension splitting helps the household. Shifting eligible pension income to a lower-income spouse can protect one person's OAS. Sometimes it just pushes the other spouse into a higher bracket. Look at the combined after-tax result rather than one cheque.

Timing has one more wrinkle. CRA uses the income on your filed return to set how much OAS it withholds from your monthly payments in the period that follows. A single high-income year can therefore shrink your deposits for months afterward, until a lower-income return resets them.

None of this means protecting OAS at any cost. Sometimes paying some recovery tax now is cheaper than larger forced RRIF payments later. The goal is spending you can sustain after everything is paid.

Before your next planned withdrawal, ask your advisor or accountant one question: after income tax and any OAS recovery, how much of this money will I actually get to spend? Then compare that number across your RRIF, your TFSA and your spouse's accounts before you decide which one to draw from.


Sources

  1. Girard Wealth - OAS Clawback 2026: Threshold, How It Works, and How to Reduce It - 2026-10-27. https://girardwealth.ca/insights/oas-clawback/