• Home
  • B.C.'s Top Income Tax Hike Buys Little Revenue at a Steep Cost to Growth
B.C.'s Top Income Tax Hike Buys Little Revenue at a Steep Cost to Growth
By Julie Sheremeto profile image Julie Sheremeto
3 min read

B.C.'s Top Income Tax Hike Buys Little Revenue at a Steep Cost to Growth

The case for raising it is not foolish, and it deserves a fair hearing. The B.C. Ministry of Finance has long reported that the top 1% of earners contribute a disproportionate share of personal income tax revenue. That income funds hospitals, transit and schools, which are part of why people want to live here. The usual rebuttal, that high earners will simply leave, is often overstated. A specialist with a practice in Kelowna, a family rooted in the Okanagan and a rental portfolio that would cost a fortune to unwind is not packing for Calgary over a few points of tax. Supporters are right that mass flight is unlikely.

Where the revenue estimate breaks

The weakness is not that high earners move. It is that the income they report changes shape.

A salaried employee has almost no control over when or how they are paid. A business owner has a great deal. In B.C., active business income inside a Canadian-controlled private corporation is taxed at a provincial rate of 2% on the first $500,000. When the personal top rate rises, the sensible response for an incorporated owner is to leave more money in the company and pay out less as salary or dividends. That income is not gone, but it no longer shows up in the top personal bracket this year, and possibly not for many years.

Others adjust differently. Some time their income across years, some shift effort toward assets that grow rather than pay, and some just decline the extra contract or the weekend shift because the reward has shrunk. None of this requires a moving truck. Each adjustment is reasonable for the household that makes it. Taken together, they shrink the very base the higher rate was supposed to tax.

This explains why a top-rate increase tends to raise less than a simple calculation predicts. The forecast assumes top-bracket income holds steady once the rate goes up. In practice, the portion of that income that is most flexible, and that belongs disproportionately to business owners and the self-employed, is exactly the portion that responds. The province also becomes more dependent on a small group whose reported income can swing sharply from one year to the next, so a soft year at the top can open a gap in the budget.

The cost that shows up in a mortgage file

The growth cost goes beyond total investment. It changes how capital moves. Profits retained inside a company to avoid personal tax are profits not used for a down payment, a renovation or a second property held personally. Owners who pay themselves less to manage tax also report less income, and that weakens their position when they need to qualify for a mortgage. CMHC's self-employed program permits a 15% gross-up on self-employed income in some cases, but that is a partial offset. It does not fix a file built around minimizing personal income.

For investors, the full picture includes more than income tax. B.C. also charges property transfer tax and the Speculation and Vacancy Tax. Real decisions about whether to buy, hold or restructure are made against the combined load, and a higher top rate pushes more of those decisions toward deferral and corporate holding rather than active deployment.

A better way to judge it

The conventional view still applies to one group. When top-bracket income comes mainly from salaries with little flexibility, a rate increase will mostly be paid as intended. The question to ask about any top-rate change is how much of the affected income can change its form or timing. In a province with a large share of incorporated professionals, owner-operators and real estate investors, that share is substantial.

If you are in that group, now is a good time to review the balance between corporate retention and personal draw against your borrowing plans for the next few years. The tax you defer and the mortgage you want to qualify for are tied together, and they work best when planned together.